In that case I would get a used Mazda. Mazda has a partnership with Toyota since 2015 and is one of the few brands that are increasing in quality, rather than cheaping out as time goes on. There cars are relatively reliable and no major recall (except for the cylinder deactivation that should be avoided anyways) has been issued. I don't hear whether by Scotty or on the forum any widespread mechanical failure on those. I probably would place 3rd on the reliability rank if I had to.

I don't have the time to recharge or the money to buy a Tesla.

My top quality brands are Honda/Acura, Toyota/Honda, Mazda, Subaru, and A brand I can’t get here... Suzuki. 

If these brands didn’t exist, I’d have a though time picking a car. 

I’d probably just go by looks.

Mazda and Subaru also make some reliable products. Honda is also okay but they’re reliability is no longer neck n neck with Toyota anymore and I’d say they’ve fallen to Subaru levels if not slightly below. Mazdas and Subarus could last as long as a modern Honda but not quite close to Toyota as the Toyota will still outlast all 3 brands.

I would go with a Mazda and Subaru.

I don't remember Suzuki making any reliable cars, EVER. They make good motorcycles but cars, nope. Now if you meant Subaru then that's a different story. 

For me, it would look like this:

1. Sports Car: Porsche 911 GT3/RS

2. Sedan: Porsche Panamera GTS Turbo

3. SUV: Porsche Cayenne GTS Turbo

4. Truck: Chevy Silverado 2500 Duramax