Car Questions

S.M. Kilmer & Assoc...
 
Notifications
Clear all

S.M. Kilmer & Associates vs. J.D. Power & Associates

  

1
Topic starter

After several months on this forum, seeing list after list, compilation after compilation, poll after poll, it’s obvious that S.M. Kilmer & Associates would disagree strongly with J.D. Power & Associates.

Sure, there are a few overlaps, but by and large, the list is divergent rather convergent.

Here is the list:

J.D. Power 2021 Vehicle Dependability Study most dependable models, by segment (assesses 2018 models)

 

Most dependable model: Porsche 911

Compact car: Volkswagen Beetle

Compact premium car: Lexus ES

Midsize car: Kia Optima

Midsize premium car: Genesis G80

Midsize sporty car: Chevrolet Camaro

Large car: Toyota Avalon

Small premium car: BMW 2 Series

Compact SUV: Buick Envision

Compact premium SUV: Porsche Macan

Midsize SUV: Kia Sorento

Midsize premium SUV: Lexus GX

Large SUV: Chevrolet Tahoe

Small SUV: Kia Sportage

Small premium SUV: Mercedes-Benz GLA

Minivan: Toyota Sienna

Midsize pickup: Nissan Frontier

Large light-duty pickup: Toyota Tundra

Large heavy-duty pickup: Chevrolet Silverado HD


Topic Tags
13 Answers
7

There's a Mercedes on the list. Enough said.

 

Also, the Tahoe ( {blackemo}:laughtertotears: ) which we have already had complaints about here on the forum. The Camaro is also laughable and the Buick Envision is GM's first all-Chinese made vehicle so that should tell you something right there.

 

Porsche is pretty reliable, but I'm with @InThrustWeTrust...definitely not reliable enough to be a segment leader.

 

Kia being on the list is also hilarious and to top it off, the VW Beetle is rated Most Reliable (anything). Yup. Same BS as usual.


Exactly! Certainly not the ‘most’.


6

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zSBsq6HBBzw


caws


Lmao I watch that video lol.


"Did you guys just rent this whole building out just to show the cars you couldn't sell." Lol got me laughing so hard.


3

Porsche gave the most money this year it seems. 🤔


3

If car commercals were honest...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gmQE4qdb9fg


2

You had me at Most dependable model : Porsche 911


Seriously.


Toy model maybe


@g-t I know right!


2

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=zKN5Wl4uTyY


Geez. J.D. Power is a load of crap.


It’s important to do all the research before you buy a car and listen to some of these mechanics that actually work on cars.


2

 

1. This is 3 year reliability

2. Meh the data itself isn't reliable

Plus they are paying JD Power so...


15,000 is a respectable sample size


2

This list is so bad! I started laughing as soon as I saw the Porsche 911.


1

only thing i know for certain, kerem does not like a F-150 and the 5.4 is horrible 🤣 


lol I actually do like it but I trust Car Wizard and Mod Man so that is why I don't have a positive approach to it when someone asks for it
Also I think most would agree with me on the 5.4 3 valve v8 thing
Thanks for the input lol I'm famous

I really like how everyone is backing me up all the time thank you so much


@kerem No problem.


1

All the Kia's! Even the Sorento... 🤣


1

At 6:14

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EDFENEafrog


Thanks @g-t! Scotty is hilarious.


You are welcome!


1

SM Kilmer best car Study:

 

 

 

Most dependable model:1994 Celica

Compact car: 1994 Celica

Compact premium car: 1994 Celica

Midsize car:1994 Celica

Midsize premium car:1994 Celica

Midsize sporty car:1994 Celica

Large car:1994 Celica

Small premium car1994 Celica

 SUV:1994 Celica

Compact premium SUV:1994 Celica

Midsize SUV:1994 Celica

Midsize premium SUV:1994 Celica

Large SUV:1994 Celica

Small SUV:1994 Celica

Small premium SUV:1994 Celica

Minivan:1994 Celica

Midsize pickup:1994 Celica

Large light-duty pickup: 1994 Celica

heavy-duty pickup: 1994 Celica


Accurate.


0

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xTfS0nAgfuE


These commercials would be a tiny bit less cringy if the things people said in them wasn't completely idiotic. $80,000 ???


@mountainmanjoe
Ikr, also, what do these people do to get there. Plus these people obviously know how else are they THERE guessing that a Chevy Malibu is a BMW.


Lol I remember these. Scotty should hire him for his own Chevy commercials.


Share: