Car Questions

Best car for 17 yea...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Best car for 17 year old?

  

0
Topic starter

Hi, Scotty Kilmer! I love your videos. I just turned 17 and am ready to buy my very first car. My budget goes up to $8000 and I want something very reliable, kind of sporty, and of good value. Which of the following choices are the best?

1) 2012-2014 camry se

2) Mazda 3 ( are they reliable?)

3) 2013- 2015 civic

4) Toyota corolla

5) Honda fit

Thanks, again!


I am leaning towards the mazda 3, but am unsure of the reliability of mazdas.


Clarification: Which model year Mazda 3?


4 Answers
0

Between those get the Civic with manual transmission. 


My parents are against the manual transmission, but thanks for the quick reply!


If this is the case, get a Corolla.


0

I agree with yaser, if you need an automatic, go with Toyota.  The Corolla or the Camry.  But don't trust anyone.  Always have a trusted mechanic check it out first.


0

Corolla or Camry. Avoid the Mazda. 


does the 2012-14 camry have problems with the transmission because I have heard that?


0

I would go with Honda Civic with manual > Toyota Corolla with automatic, in that order.  

The 2013+ newer Mazda 3’s (2.5L naturally aspirated Skyactiv-G I4 with 6-speed Skyactic-Drive automatic) are reliable but might be above your budget.

I would avoid the 2012-2014 Toyota Camry’s due to potential transmission headaches down the line.  2015-2017 would be better, but may be above your budget.


i looked up manual civics and manual corollas and saw a 13 corolla s with 150k manual for 7k. Are the manual corollas worse than the civics cause the civics are so pricey.


@andrew-p the 5-speed manual Corolla for that generation (model years 2012-2018) was fine. If you can get a manual Corolla that’s a good choice.  Stay away from CVT transmissions.


do you think i would stall the engine ever because manuals are hard to shift


@andrew-p you will have to learn to drive a manual first, but once you do you will get the hang of it.  It’s worth it, because manuals will usually outlast automatics.


Share: