I thought about this one today and it may be a somewhat silly question. Are All-Terrain tires better at repelling nails and other junk in the road that can puncture your tires vs all-season highway tires? I put All-Terrain tires on my '99 Ranger Off-Road, mainly because I like the look, and I figured they'll hold up better on the pothole riddled roads of the Midwest. The Ranger has never picked up a screw or nail with the All-Terrains, and it gets driven on the same roads way more often than the Mustang does. My 2017 Mustang has all-season tires and has gone through 2 tires and a patch from screws and nails getting into them. I work in an industrial area where scrappers love to dig metal out of dumpsters, and they often lose nails and other sharp stuff.