Hey Scotty! big fan hailing from New Jersey! I am currently sittingin a 2017 Subaru Impreza Sport wagon with about 62k miles. I am coming from a family that has owned trucks and SUVs all of my life. With proper maintenance we have had no issues, I owned a 2007 Nissan Xterra since 2009 and decided to trade in for a 2017 Subaru Impreza and with just under 10k miles I do not find enjoyment as i do with trucks/SUVs. I also have a gut feeling this car will give me trouble in the future. I drive 18k/year so comfort and reliability is very important. I found a local dealer with 2005 Toyota 4Runner with 86k miles. Looks good, runs good, well maintained, clean carfax and no rust. https://www.centralgroupnj.com/details/used-2005-toyota-4runner/82813241 Do you think its worth selling my subaru and buying the 4runner? Thanks!
I also have a gut feeling this car will give me trouble in the future.

Why would you want to trade in your 5yr old fuel efficient wagon, for a 17yr old gas hog?! Do you even need all those seats?
Not from a dealer and do not trust Carfax.