Car Questions

Notifications
Clear all

Father Knows Best*

  

0
Topic starter

Short: How do you tell a friend/family member they're wrong about something automotive, but respectfully?

Long: I've been living on my own for about 6 years now: once I had a decent paying job and was fully able to support myself. Turning 27 this year. I was chatting with my dad on the phone, and I mentioned that I had to replace rear rotors & pads on my car (2011 Mazda3, the rear rotors are scored and beaten like someone took a hammer to it, pads are worn at an angle. Severe clanging noises and car shakes from the rear when braking and slight scraping just with normal motion. Calipers might even need to be replaced) along with the leak in the AC system and other gremlins.

He immediately became agitated, and his response: "There's nothing wrong with your car. It's a reliable car. You're wrong."

Keep in mind, this is the same guy who drove his truck around for a year with a transmission that wouldn't shift into 4th gear, and only sometimes would shift into reverse or park, and said that was "fine". Or buying the wrong brake pads because they were a few bucks cheaper and he "could make them fit". But it's always been like this. The only time something is wrong with mine or my brothers' vehicles is when he deems it. 

Now, he hasn't even sat in the passenger seat of my car in 6 years, much less lived with MY daily driver. And yet without looking or listening he's making wild claims that nothing is wrong. He clearly is full of it, or thinks that the car needing any work is some sort of personal offense against him. Some folks just won't acknowledge anything that might make them seem wrong....

How do I respectfully point out to him that what he is saying is ludicrous, in a way that actually changes his mind, but without crossing the 5th commandment? Driving cross country to my parent's place, paying a mechanic to make a house call inspection in an ambush style "I told you so" confrontation seems a little bit much, though it's crossed my mind. 


This is a good example of why I talk to myself - to get an expert opinion.


4 Answers
7

Don't waste your time.  Just be glad you have a Dad and love him the best you can. 


This!


Great answer. 👍 👍 


Yeah you're probably right. So long as he doesn't decide to check it out while I'm there for the 4th of July, shouldn't be any issue. He takes these things so personally. But I'm not driving that huge distance, holiday traffic, with brakes like that just to humor him.


7

That kind of thinking was common with people who lived through the Great Depression - don't spend money on anything not absolutely necessary. (Hey, that truck still has 3 perfectly good gears and you can just park where you're not going to need reverse, why spend money fixing something that can still be used as-is? Who cares if your car shakes and makes noise, it still stops doesn't it?)

Since you are only 27 I assume that's not the case here but perhaps your dad picked up the habit from older family members. In any event, I'd just quietly repair your brakes without telling him and just let him just go on thinking that he's right, you're not going to change his mind. Take it from someone whose parents are both long gone, it's not worth getting into an argument with him over this.


That's probably a good take. It's probably best to just let it lie.


Great and compassionate advice @chucktobias. Thank you.


4

I would suggest reading about the Dunning -Kruger Effect - there is no point in using logic and data to change the opinion of people that think they know everything.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect

 


I HAVE to add a line I just heard, "I’m not concerned with facts, not if they interfere with my beliefs" I think that is the TL;DR of Dunning Kruger.


3

Offer him the old damaged parts to use on his car 😆   "Here ... you want them?"


I kid. Listen to Chuck.


Share: