I’m shopping for a used truck. For the sake of towing about 8,000lbs and to have the best reliability I’ve narrowed it down to either a Toyota Tundra or a Chevy/GMC 2500HD diesel.
I’m in no rush, and I’m shopping around at dealerships or private sale if I can find it.
Do you have an opinion on what I’ve narrowed it to? Which one would give the best, safest overall towing experience? Any other factors to consider?
I wouldn't get either one. You didn't mention years for either one and there's a likely chance that either one of them will have high mileage (at least 200k mileage or more).
Since you did mention a diesel pickup, have you considered a Dodge Ram with a Cummins engine? Those trucks will last you a very long time with proper maintenance.
I totally agree with you about the mileage. I am flexible about the year, so most I’m looking at are higher in mileage.
The reason I’ve ruled out the Ram 2500, isn’t because of the excellent Cummins engine, but their weaker transmission when compared to the Chevy’s Allison transmission. The Allison is best by far, and the Duramax is close enough to the Cummins in quality and reliability.
Also Scotty’s recent video shows how much more above average long term maintenance costs the Ram has.
The 2014-21 V8 Tundra is very reliable, and can tow 8000 pounds alright. Much more than that and I would agree with @kp about a Cummins Ram 2500.
As far as the “best, safest” towing experience, then actually the 6.6 Duramax Chevy would be best. It will be a little more stable on the highway than the Tundra, and most people think it has better throttle response than the Ram. It just may not have the lifespan of the Toyota or Cummins Ram.
Welcome new member.
Thank you!