2007 Lexus ES 350, automatic, about 180,000 miles.
Cold-start rattle began ~100 miles ago, worsened over ~60 miles driving. ~40 miles ago, high-pitched whining started both idling (rattle) AND driving (whining). Parked immediately, sitting 2 weeks undriven. No CEL.
Independent shop inspection: "Removed drive belt to verify noise not accessory—noise present belt-off. Stethoscope confirms noise from front bank behind timing cover. Timing component noise, possibly chain slap from bad tensioner. Referred to dealer."
3 Louisville quotes:
-
Dealership (phone quote, worse case scenerio): $8,900
-
Independent shop 1(phone quote): $3,000–$7,000 range
-
Independent shop 2:(phone quote) $1,800 labor + dealership parts
Drive low miles yearly, want reliability/no breakdowns. Considering dump for 2005–06 Camry/ES330.
Questions:
-
Front bank/timing cover noise at 180k miles + rattle idling + whine driving = just tensioner/o-rings, or stretched chain/guides/VVT damage likely?
-
$1,800 labor + parts realistic for full 2GR-FE front bank timing fix per inspection, or bait-and-switch once inside? What must be included?
-
Lexus $8,900 vs. independents—which aligns with "timing component/chain slap" at 180k miles?
-
With inspection + 180k miles + progressing symptoms, would you:
-
Fix (which type of shop?), or
-
Sell AS-IS and buy simpler Camry/ES330?
-
-
Key questions for independent shop BEFORE work to avoid $5k surprise mid-job?
Front bank/timing cover noise at 180k miles + rattle idling + whine driving = just tensioner/o-rings, or stretched chain/guides/VVT damage likely?
without xray vision, you won't know until it gets opened up.
$1,800 labor + parts realistic for full 2GR-FE front bank timing fix per inspection, or bait-and-switch once inside? What must be included?
That would be the starting cost.
Lexus $8,900 vs. independents—which aligns with "timing component/chain slap" at 180k miles?
The dealership will always cost more. Their rates are higher, and they don't repair anything, only replace.
would you:
Fix (which type of shop?), or
Sell AS-IS and buy simpler Camry/ES330?
Depends on your budget
Key questions for independent shop BEFORE work
use a trustworthy shop, ideally one you know through word of mouth. Check their reviews. Make sure all labour and parts are warrantied.
to avoid $5k surprise mid-job?
It's always a possibility. That's just how car repair works. There's no magic crystal ball that tells you what the condition inside the engine is.
I would not put a huge amount of money (thousands of dollars) into a 19-year-old high mileage car.
