Car Questions

IIHS releases a new...
 
Notifications
Clear all

IIHS releases a new and tougher side crash test (Mazda Cx-5 takes the W). Any thoughts?

  

0
Topic starter

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HHfJR7dBgu0

New side-impact tests from the IIHS and the Mazda CX-5 took the win with a good rating. The worst ones were the Honda HR-V and Mitsubishi Eclipse Cross.

Here is the list of all SUVs tested so far from my knowledge in this new side test (I am probably missing some):

Mazda Cx-5 - Good

Nissan Rogue- Acceptable

Honda CR-V - Acceptable

Toyota Rav4 - Acceptable

Subaru Forester - Acceptable

Buick Encore - Acceptable

Mitsubishi Outlander - Acceptable

Audi Q3 - Acceptable

Volvo XC40 - Acceptable

Jeep Renegade - Marginal

Kia Sportage - Marginal

Hyundai Tucson - Marginal

Chevrolet Equinox - Marginal

Ford Escape - Marginal

Jeep Compass - Marginal

Honda HR-V - Poor

Mitsubishi Eclipse Cross - Poor


Topic Tags
2 Answers
0

Well of course that's the weak part and smaller vehicles they making them later so they're going to crunch anymore they deliberately make them to crunch for safety from front and rear impacts but of course the side impact another story and crunch is too much and crunches the driver and the passenger


0

As a reference the old test was 3,300lbs at 31mph (Honda Accord). The new test is closer to some Honda Pilot options at 37.

I've heard some people claim it's a gov conspiracy to stop ppl from buying cars.1): The IIHS is not a gov agency (they work for insurance companies, so not any better). 2) To me: With more people driving bigger vehicles it doesn't seem unreasonable that they updated the test. And I sure can't afford to test out the cars myself, so I'm going to have to trust someone's word. 

 

I will say the scariest accident I ever saw was a mustang trying to blow through a busy 3 lane 4 way intersection in the middle of a city that it was WAY too late for, easily 65-70mph, engine roaring. The cross traffic had the green light before the mustang even entered the intersection. Clipped the front corner of a Buick in the middle lane that started to move forward. Everyone was ok, but a fraction of a second difference and that mustang would have slammed square into the driver's door of that Buick. Stopping bad driving will go a lot further to safer roads, but having a car that keeps you safe to play the blame game afterwards shouldn't be understated either. 


Share: